Online: | |
Visits: | |
Stories: |
By Adam J. Pearson
The Fear of Shining Bright
Every day, we find ourselves inundated with images of people who excel. Our popular media glorifies athletes, business moguls, and wealthy musical performers. Our advertisements favour the most beautiful and handsome models to showcase their products and set up standards of perfection, which unconsciously influence us even though we may passionately deny it (Markman, 2010).
We grow up in consumerist cultures that offer countless products as miracle cures for all of our insecurities, symbolic tools that companies promise will help us shine as the great people we are meant to be. Of course, studies have repeatedly shown that trying to compensate for our insecurities by buying new products only ends up making us feel even more miserable than we did before (Morin, 2015).
In short, our culture praises the charismatic individual who lets their strengths, talents, and beauty shine. And we feel naturally drawn to be expressive in this way. It’s part of our yearning for self-actualization, our wish to grow, and unfold, and be our boldest, most fearless, and most creative selves (Olson, 2013).
We yearn to shine and hunger for perfect self-expression. And yet we sometimes find it incredibly difficult to do so. Why? Many factors sometimes seem to hold us back. Anxiety. Shame. Feeling like we lack the resources, time, and talent that we need. Perhaps the most powerful factor of all, however, is the fear of shining bright — the fear of failure, the fear of embarrassing ourselves, and the fear of being seen as pompous and thus, being disliked by others. Moreover, as Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT) points out, behind every fear, there is a thought, a story, that may or may not be true (Boyes, 2013).
Facing the Thoughts Behind the Fears
If you find that any of these fears are holding you back from excelling in your strengths and fully expressing yourself, I would invite you to see if there’s a thought behind the fear that you can investigate. For example, in my own case, I noticed that one reason I was holding back my own self-expression was that I was afraid people would see me as arrogant and wouldn’t want to spend time with me as a result. Behind this fear, I found a thought that said:
“If I don’t downplay my strengths, I’ll be arrogant and people won’t want to be around me.”
I had long believed this thought story to be true, but had never really investigated it, so I decided to subject it to some honest inquiry. As you read, see if any of these answers to the inquiry questions resonate with thoughts or feelings inside of you.
Is the thought “if I don’t downplay my strengths, I’ll be arrogant and people won’t want to be around me” true?
It certainly feels true, but can I absolutely know that it’s true? If I’m being honest, I have to admit that no, I can’t. It feels like an assumption that many people have told me, but that I never questioned, a piece of ‘conventional wisdom’ that I simply accepted on face value.
How do I feel and react when I believe this thought?
I feel less passionate, more held back, more restrained, less free to boldly express and be myself without inhibitions. I feel like i’m turning down the dials on my self-expression and best qualities so as not to annoy or offend others. I feel afraid of really shining in my authenticity because I don’t want other people to see me as arrogant or pompous. I don’t want them to see me as proud because if they do, then they won’t want to be around me (this is good old shame, the fear of disconnection). So, I hold back and feel constricted and inwardly contracted instead.
Who would I be without this thought?
I’d feel more free to just flow and be myself, more at ease to express and share with others, more open and authentic, and less held back by an inner pressure to contain my creativity.
Can I find a single stress-free reason to hold on to this thought?
No, I can’t. The truth is that this thought stresses me out unnecessarily. Just because we’re being creative and authentic doesn’t mean we have to put other people down and make them feel inferior in the process. We can encourage each other and cheer each other on to be the boldest, most creative, and most self-actualized people that we can be. We can follow our bliss together, each in our own unique ways and root for our collective success without sacrificing our integrity.
Can I see a reason to drop this thought? And we’re not being asked to drop it.
Yes. I’d feel less restrained, more free to be myself and ‘do my thing’ boldly and authentically. Doing that might even inspire others to follow their own passions and play with their own creativity. It might help me create things that others enjoy or find helpful too.
Now, take the original thought and turn it around to its opposite.
If I turn around the original thought, I end up with this new one:
“I can let my strengths shine without being arrogant and people will still want to be around me.”
Is this new thought as true or truer than the old one? Yes, it is even truer than the original thought. There are many great artists and performers and achievers in the world who boldly let their talents shine while remaining humble and people are not repulsed by them; indeed, they tend to be drawn to them and inspired by them.
If you find a thought behind a fear is holding you back from fully expressing yourself, I’d invite you to try write it down, ask the questions above about it, and turn it around. See if the turnaround might be true or truer than the original thought. Inquiring is a way of revealing the truth or falsehood of our beliefs if we’re willing to question and see things in new and refreshing ways.
Background to The Celebrate Yourself Exercise
Byron Katie’s inquiry method, which I exemplified above, can be a helpful way to investigate the thoughts that hold us back from truly excelling, expressing ourselves, and shining as we are meant to shine. Another exercise that I have found helpful is the Celebrate Yourself Exercise.
Because of thoughts like the one we explored above, we may feel reluctant to really let ourselves be honest about the things that are good and valuable about ourselves. If shame is the belief that we are fundamentally bad, deficient, or not enough, and therefore, unworthy of love and belonging, then it’s worth seeing the ways in which we are, in fact, good.
Listing things that we like about ourselves isn’t always the most intuitive activity for most of us, but Dr. Jennifer Vilhauer (2015) reports that she has found the practice to be tremendously effective at fostering a sense of well-being and reinforcing the freedom to express ourselves. The version of the exercise that she recommends to her patients in therapy is the following:
- Keep a pad of paper next to your bed and every night before you go to sleep, write down three things you liked about yourself that day.
- In the morning, read the list before you get out of bed.
- Do this everyday for 30 days.
These don’t have to be big things, like I am a kind person; they can be simple, such as I like that I held the door for my co-worker, or I like that I didn’t lose my temper in traffic today, or I like that I am making the effort to try this exercise even if I’m not sure it will work…
This is a particularly helpful exercise for people who suffer from depression and “spend a good deal of time thinking about what they don’t like about themselves” (Vilhaueur, 2015). However, it’s helpful to all of us. Dr. Vilhauer explains how here:
Research also shows that it requires more attentional effort to disengage from a negative thought process than a neutral one.(2) This simple-to-do but nonetheless effortful exercise essentially helps you build the strength to disengage from any negative thought stream; redirects your attention to positive aspects of yourself; and retrains your selective attention bias.
As you do this, you not only start to become aware of more of your positive attributes, they become more available to you as you interpret events around you. Compliments become something you can hear and accept because they are more congruent with your new view of yourself. You start to interpret events occurring around you in a less self-critical way. If you stick with it, over time this has a compounding effect that elevates your overall sense of self-worth—and, subsequently, your well-being.
I have found this exercise very helpful as well. In addition, though, there’s another version of the exercise that can produce a very deep and different experience because it adds a social dimension to the practice. I call this practice the Celebrate Yourself Exercise. It can be done alone, but it’s most rewarding when done with a partner.
How to do the Celebrate Yourself Exercise
Here are the steps of the Celebrate Yourself Exercise. This exercise can be done either while:
The first option is the most physically intimate and the three that follow involve progressively less visual contact, and thus may feel progressively less vulnerable. Begin by choosing the option out of the four with which you and your partner feel the most comfortable.
It is easiest to do this exercise with a friend, lover, or family member, with whom you already feel safe and trusting, but it can be a powerful exercise to do with a coworker as well, in a respectful workshop setting, for example. In any case, begin by choosing your partner and agreeing with your partner on the one of the four communication options given above. With the logistics made clear, you can proceed to the steps of the Celebrate Yourself Exercise.
Overview
I celebrate myself, and sing myself,
And what I assume you shall assume,
For every atom belonging to me as good belongs to you.
~ Walt Whitman, Leaves of Grass (1892)
This exercise is elegantly simple. We will begin by telling our partner in as much detail as possible, what we like or love about ourselves. We will then listen while they do the same about themselves. And then we will debrief about how we felt doing it and thank each other for listening and offering us a safe space in which to practice the power of vulnerability.
We normally don’t list our positive traits to others out of a fear of annoying people by ‘bragging,’ but showing off is not our intention here. We’re not just “tooting our own horn,” as my grandfather used to say. Our intention is to find as many things that we like about ourselves and share them in as much detail as possible in the presence of a witness, a caring partner. We are going to temporarily drop the thought that it’s impolite to celebrate ourselves and we’re going to go all out as we look inward for as many things we can find to love about ourselves. This is an exercise in self-love unfolding in a nonjudgmental social context, which gives it even more power and makes it feel even more real.
When your partner is sharing, it is very important to be supportive and caring and not mock them or ridicule them for what they are sharing. If you feel so inspired, you can even reinforce the points they share when you recognize them to be true by celebrating them yourself with comments like “yes, that’s true!”, “yeah!”, “yes, I notice that about you too,” or “yes, I value that about you.” It’s important not to try to refute your partner’s claims here; we’re just trying to offer each other an encouraging, nonjudgmental ear. As you will find when it’s your turn to share, listing things we like about ourselves can be a vulnerable experience, so it’s important to make your partner feel safe enough to do so just as you will want them to do for you. It may feel a little awkward and silly at first and if so, that’s okay. Get your giggles out and keep going. There are no wrong answers so we can relax into the practice.
The Steps of the Celebrate Yourself Exercise
Now, let’s get started:
In short, the steps are: share and listen, share and listen, debrief, and thank. Celebrate yourself and listen to your partner do the same; in this way, you get to celebrate each other and practice self-love with a real audience. This gives it a real social dynamic that can feel very empowering and thrilling despite the fear that may arise.
Examples of Sharing from the Celebrate Yourself Exercise
You have options in what you choose to share in the Celebrate Yourself Exercise. For example, you can share a specific thing you did on one occasion (e.g. “I like how I remained calm when my boss was yelling in my face today”) or a general quality that you find in yourself (e.g. “I love how I really try to listen to people and take an interest in what they are saying to me.
You can also choose to share things that are more or less personal and vulnerable, depending on your comfort level with your partner (e.g. “I like how I’m open to trying new foods” versus “I love how I learned to set healthy boundaries after I was sexually assaulted”). Naturally, the second sharing involves more vulnerability than the first and may require a greater sense of safety and trust with your partner.
Finally, you can go into more or less explanatory detail. You can be more or less precise about what you like and love about yourself.
Here is a list of actual examples of authentic sharing from the Celebrate Yourself Exercise from some of the courageous men and women with whom I’ve done this powerful practice:
Final Words: The Celebrate Yourself Exercise for Building Intimacy
As a final note, the Celebrate Yourself Exercise naturally tends to help build a stronger connection between the two people who practice it because it involves offering one another a safe space in which to be emotionally vulnerable. However, to enhance its intimacy-building potential even more, you can add two final steps to those listed above to produce this
Intimacy-Building Version:
In closing, the Celebrate Yourself Exercise is very simple, but also very powerful as well. I’d recommend that you give it a shot with someone with whom you feel comfortable and see what happens. You just might find yourself discovering things about yourself that you never really appreciated before. In addition, if you try the Intimacy-Building Version of the Celebrate Yourself Exercise, you might find yourself feeling surprisingly closer to a loved one after only a few minutes of open sharing, a small investment for a considerably large and valuable reward.
References
Boyes, Alice. (2013). Cognitive restructuring: six ways to do cognitive restructuring. Psychology Today. Retrieved from https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/in-practice/201301/cognitive-restructuring
Markman, Art. (2010). What does advertizing do? Psychology Today. Retrieved from https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/ulterior-motives/201008/what-does-advertising-do
Morin, Amy. (2013). Why you should embrace your insecurities and not mask them. Psychology Today. Retrieved from https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/what-mentally-strong-people-dont-do/201506/why-you-should-embrace-your-insecurities-and-not
Olson, Ann. (2013). The theory of self-actualization: mental illness, creativity, and art. Psychology Today. Retrieved from https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/theory-and-psychopathology/201308/the-theory-self-actualization
Vilhauer, Jennice. (2015). One exercise sure to make you feel better about yourself. Psychology Today. Retrieved from https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/living-forward/201501/one-exercise-sure-make-you-feel-better-about-yourself
Read More from Adam Pearson at http://philosophadam.wordpress.com/